[dm-devel] [PATCH 0/9] dm-crypt patches
Ondrej Kozina
okozina at redhat.com
Tue Apr 8 15:25:17 UTC 2014
Hi,
I ran all tests again and with new version and everything passed even on
raid5 back end, so it's right time to paste here some performance results:
Requirements:
------------
http://okozina.fedorapeople.org/dmcrypt-tests.tar.xz
compiled fio package
Performance tests are based on script in subdirectory 1/ in
http://okozina.fedorapeople.org/dmcrypt-tests.tar.xz
The result tables were aggregated from output of following fio command:
fio --output=log --latency-log=log --bandwidth-log=log \
--name=global --rw=$3 --size=1G --bsrange=1k-128k \
--filename=$1 \
--name=job1 --name=job2 --name=job3 --name=job4 \
--end_fsync=1
$1 - test device
$3 - read/write mode see explanation of TEST NAME column below
HW:
---
2-socket machine Intel(R) Xeon(TM) CPU 3.40GHz (4 logical CPUs, without
HW acceleration for AES!)
4GB RAM
4x SEAGATE ST336753LC (rotational drive)
One disk was used for system data, the rest for testing
Explanation for tables below:
-----------------------------
In column TEST NAME:
- "disk_nocrypt" stands for pure device w/o any encryption in effect
(it's single device or raid5 device using md)
- "zero" stands for encryption over dm-zero target. Basically this test
is trying to measure the performance of dm-crypt core alone.
- "disk" is real device (same as in "disk_nocrypt") with encryption set
up over it.
following suffixes after dash in TABLE NAME column:
(all correspond to permissible values for fio --rw option)
- read = sequential reads
- write = sequential writes
- randread = random reads
- randwrite = random writes
- rw = sequential mixed reads and writes
- randrw = random mixed reads and writes
Any mixed option above has separate line for aggregated READs and WRITEs
operations.
For encryption I used aes-xts-plain64 cipher, but please note that the
machine doesn't provide HW acceleration for AES algorithm.
The column AGGRB_A stands for results with vanilla 3.14
The column AGGRB_B stands for results with all Mikulas's patches applied.
The interesting results are prefixed with "zero-" and "disk-". The
"disk_nocrypt-" results are just for reference to see real limits of HW.
The "zero-" prefixed lines doesn't require to be published multiple
times but it can serve to demonstrate scatter of results even on idling
machine (except for running tests).
The single device tests:
TEST NAME OPERATION AGGRB_A KB/s AGGRB_B KB/s DIFF A->B
------------------------- --------- ------------ ------------ ---------
disk_nocrypt-read READ 260289 259339 -0.36 %
disk_nocrypt-write WRITE 242950 242922 -0.01 %
disk_nocrypt-randread READ 53095 52195 -1.70 %
disk_nocrypt-randwrite WRITE 193665 194482 0.42 %
disk_nocrypt-rw READ 64050 64037 -0.02 %
disk_nocrypt-rw WRITE 64581 64567 -0.02 %
disk_nocrypt-randrw READ 16792 17235 2.64 %
disk_nocrypt-randrw WRITE 16796 17239 2.64 %
zero-read READ 187614 309748 65.10 %
zero-write WRITE 240871 332301 37.96 %
zero-randread READ 299024 325476 8.85 %
zero-randwrite WRITE 108506 123805 14.10 %
zero-rw READ 81694 106583 30.47 %
zero-rw WRITE 82370 107465 30.47 %
zero-randrw READ 60794 85574 40.76 %
zero-randrw WRITE 60810 85597 40.76 %
disk-read READ 232603 238258 2.43 %
disk-write WRITE 119649 218601 82.70 %
disk-randread READ 52578 52249 -0.63 %
disk-randwrite WRITE 153878 173487 12.74 %
disk-rw READ 61341 64629 5.36 %
disk-rw WRITE 61849 65164 5.36 %
disk-randrw READ 16251 15229 -6.29 %
disk-randrw WRITE 16255 15233 -6.29 %
md raid5 with 64KiB chunk size as basking device:
TEST NAME OPERATION AGGRB_A KB/s AGGRB_B KB/s DIFF A->B
------------------------- --------- ------------ ------------ ---------
disk_nocrypt-read READ 391405 390276 -0.29 %
disk_nocrypt-write WRITE 209736 210272 0.26 %
disk_nocrypt-randread READ 84644 84319 -0.38 %
disk_nocrypt-randwrite WRITE 30651 29174 -4.82 %
disk_nocrypt-rw READ 64533 64472 -0.09 %
disk_nocrypt-rw WRITE 65068 65005 -0.10 %
disk_nocrypt-randrw READ 18586 18827 1.30 %
disk_nocrypt-randrw WRITE 18591 18832 1.30 %
zero-read READ 190641 308042 61.58 %
zero-write WRITE 343936 306533 -10.87 %
zero-randread READ 298322 326007 9.28 %
zero-randwrite WRITE 115462 122193 5.83 %
zero-rw READ 82092 114980 40.06 %
zero-rw WRITE 82771 115932 40.06 %
zero-randrw READ 69730 90008 29.08 %
zero-randrw WRITE 69748 90032 29.08 %
disk-read READ 283207 264641 -6.56 %
disk-write WRITE 152088 176431 16.01 %
disk-randread READ 82021 81720 -0.37 %
disk-randwrite WRITE 20553 23880 16.19 %
disk-rw READ 56833 59059 3.92 %
disk-rw WRITE 57303 59548 3.92 %
disk-randrw READ 15819 16726 5.73 %
disk-randrw WRITE 15823 16730 5.73 %
md raid5 with 512KiB chunk size as basking device:
TEST NAME OPERATION AGGRB_A KB/s AGGRB_B KB/s DIFF A->B
------------------------- --------- ------------ ------------ ---------
disk_nocrypt-read READ 463151 447822 -3.31 %
disk_nocrypt-write WRITE 149476 149866 0.26 %
disk_nocrypt-randread READ 99205 98393 -0.82 %
disk_nocrypt-randwrite WRITE 34422 34535 0.33 %
disk_nocrypt-rw READ 75898 77132 1.63 %
disk_nocrypt-rw WRITE 76527 77770 1.62 %
disk_nocrypt-randrw READ 21886 21928 0.19 %
disk_nocrypt-randrw WRITE 21892 21934 0.19 %
zero-read READ 189735 305173 60.84 %
zero-write WRITE 289402 289082 -0.11 %
zero-randread READ 300373 317061 5.56 %
zero-randwrite WRITE 128128 123838 -3.35 %
zero-rw READ 81956 114558 39.78 %
zero-rw WRITE 82635 115506 39.78 %
zero-randrw READ 74406 86589 16.37 %
zero-randrw WRITE 74426 86612 16.37 %
disk-read READ 333251 399153 19.78 %
disk-write WRITE 139703 158574 13.51 %
disk-randread READ 93669 92408 -1.35 %
disk-randwrite WRITE 22994 26520 15.33 %
disk-rw READ 63573 73389 15.44 %
disk-rw WRITE 64099 73996 15.44 %
disk-randrw READ 19045 19617 3.00 %
disk-randrw WRITE 19050 19622 3.00 %
Ondrej
More information about the dm-devel
mailing list