request two icons for Bluecurve

Rahul Sundaram sundaram at redhat.com
Wed Dec 7 11:50:33 UTC 2005


Hi

>
> Tango is not only an icon theme, in fact it is mainly an icon naming 
> specification.
>
> I think it make sense to support this naming scheme, which is under 
> development at freedesktop.org.

Yes. Oxygen in KDE IIUC is using the same naming scheme. Probably a more 
important step than any particular theme design for interoperability

>
> As for the icons themselves, I can see both pluses and minuses of 
> either having an own theme or adopting Tango.
> A new theme is certainly a lot of work (maybe duplicate work) and have 
> to be maintained for a long period of time (see the subject of this 
> message) but it can improve the identity of the distro and expand the 
> community. Look at how much publicity has Tango generated.

Fedora project generally hasnt been good at marketing and the focus has 
remained mostly on churning out engineering resources on improving the 
underlying system rather than look and feel. The current development 
branch has received some attention and some of the efforts should be 
visible by now. Involving more of the community into the design process 
is a good goal. Suggestions welcome.

> However, looking back at the logo design process, I am not very 
> confident our community excels in the graphic department: basically 
> the community was not able to come with a good enough logo and in the 
> end an external (professional) design was used.
>
Partially thats the failure of the marketing project to define a set of 
guidelines for the artists before throwing open the contest and get the 
desktop/design  team on board to discuss the proposals and offer 
suggestions.  It also brought in the need to reach out better to the 
community for various Fedora related news. We learned from that and I am 
working on improving in both these fronts.

regards
Rahul




More information about the Fedora-desktop-list mailing list