Another slip in the FC6 schedule

[Alfredo Ferrari]

Seriously, I believe this is a big issue. Let me summarize:

a) there was a kernel update for FC5
b) this kernel has a known bug which could results in corrupting
    ext3 filesystems with 1k block size under heavy load
c) ... nevertheless it has been pushed out with no special warning
d) pratically all /boot partitions are ext3 1k (anaconda generated)
e) many partitions on old machine upgraded from previous versions are
    ext3 1k as well
f) experienced users could have much bigger partitions manually
    generated with 1k block size for their own fun/reasons/optimization (I
    personally have counted  already 400 GBytes of 1k, ext3, partitions
    just on my personal laptop, desktop and associated backup disks
    excluding /boot ones). In my case, most of the 1k partitions are such
    because they are subject to heavy loads with many small files

What was the rationale for releasing an official kernel update under such
dangerous conditions? Just "anaconda doesn't generate 1k partitions (not 
true BTW)"? I still believe Linux is not (yet) Windows and if features are
in the system (like 1k blocksize partitions) people can use them if 
they feel appropriate and they must work. Or perhaps there was a rush to 
push this 2.6.18 kernel out to get some extra guinea pigs finding all 
residual bugs? But this could be fair for the FC6 betas, not for FC5 where 
people is expecting reasonable stability, anyway no life-threatening
issue like a (known) filesystem corruption bug.

Now how long do we have to wait before we have an update for FC5 fixing
this critical issue? Or do we have to manually rollback kernels on all 
machines?

                  Alfredo

On Tue, 17 Oct 2006, Dave Jones wrote:

> On Tue, Oct 17, 2006 at 09:18:02AM +0200, Till Maas wrote:
> > On Tuesday 17 October 2006 05:12, Chris Adams wrote:
> >
> > > I just checked an FC5 system, and /boot (at 100M) has a 1K block size.
> > > Looking at a rawhide install I did about a week ago, its /boot (100M)
> > > also has a 1K block size.  These are from anaconda.
> >
> > My FC5 /boot (100M) has also 1K block size from anaconda. But it is only ext2,
> > do not know, whether or not this is relevant.
>
> The problem only affected ext3 (well, jbd actually).
>
> 	Dave
>
>

-- 

+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
|  Alfredo Ferrari                         ||  Tel.: +41.22.767.6119         |
|  C.E.R.N.                                ||  Fax.: +41.22.767.7555         |
|  European Laboratory for Particle Physics||                                |
|  AB Division / ATB Group                 ||  e-mail:                       |
|  1211 Geneva 23                          ||     Alfredo.Ferrari at cern.ch    |
|  Switzerland                             ||     Alfredo.Ferrari at mi.infn.it |
+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+