Don't put new packages through updates-testing

Hans de Goede j.w.r.degoede at
Fri Jun 1 13:14:23 UTC 2007

Hi all,

As already discussed on then maintainers list (using devel list for this as I 
see no reason to keep this on maintainers), the plan all of a sudden is to let 
new packages go through updates-testing.

I'm very much against this, as it adds one more step to already long process of 
getting new packages in, the current wiki page describing the process divides 
it into 14 steps and it is lacking the add to comps step (and in my case the 
update SIG wiki pag, twice once to add it to the list of packages undergoing 
review, once more to remove).

It removes much of the satisfaction of after completing the review having the 
package into the hands of the end users, the ones for which I do this. As it 
adds yet another delay.

The arguments made in favor of this is that it will be good for QA, however 
relatively few users will have updates testing enabled and new packages will 
not automatically get installed let alone used by those users. Then the 
argument in favor becomes that once we have a QA team up and running, we could 
build QA infra which autamatically installs new packages from updates-testing 
for the QA team (running still would be a manual thing). However currently all 
that infra doesn't exist, so can we please short circuit updates-testing for 
new packages, and revisit this discussion once that infra actually is there?

IOW first show that updates-testing actually is usefull (esp. for new packages) 
and then make new packages go through there.

Last but most certainly not least new packages have already had lots of QA they 
have just been reviewed! To me this forcing new packages to go through 
updates-testing is a vote of no confidence into me as a packager and a 
reviewer, and since I sink a lot of time, effort and skill into Fedora that hurts!

Yet another argument against making new-packages go through updates-testing is 
the fact that even if there were a QA team testing them, I wonder how they 
would test my latest batch of packages:

Do they happen to have an avr microcontroller development kit handy for testing 
or a gp2x handheld? Any experience with programming those?

Making package like these goto updates-testing is ridiculous.



More information about the fedora-devel-list mailing list