The community has lost control... (Was: Re: Don't put new packages through updates-testing)
fedora at leemhuis.info
Sun Jun 3 14:05:14 UTC 2007
On 03.06.2007 15:54, Ralf Corsepius wrote:
> On Sun, 2007-06-03 at 15:36 +0200, Thorsten Leemhuis wrote:
>> On 03.06.2007 15:17, Jesse Keating wrote:
>>> On Sunday 03 June 2007 02:48:35 Thorsten Leemhuis wrote:
>>>> Well, see all those discussion that happened when ACLs were added, kjoi
>>>> introduced, the freezes were introduced and bodi put in place. Sure,
>>>> there are always discussions, but all those were quite worse and there
>>>> was a lot of confusion afaics... Don't read fedora-maintainers for a
>>>> week and suddenly you are not aware of how to build or push a package.
>>> So without reading the mailing list for maintainers,
>> A low-traffic fedora-maintainers-announce was requested multiple times
>> as some contributors mentioned that fedora-maintainers is to noisy for
> One way traffic is inappropriate for a community project.
Ralf, I appreciate your opinions. But where did I say that that would
mean "One way traffic"? That was and is nowhere written or meant. Just
as fedora-extras-commit for example the fedora-maintainers-annouce list
would have a reply to another mailing list where those that want to
discuss something can discuss it. The plan was actually to subscribe
fedora-maintainers to fedora-maintainers-annouce, so announcements show
up on both list.
>> Like it or not, but for some people fedora-maintainers has to much
> Then they better should not be maintainers!
> This is Fedora, a wanna-be community project. Community projects live
> from communication. If you want it to be success, these people will have
> to leave their secret chambers and crawl into the light ;)
Some community members just want to maintain their private pet-package.
Those probably do not care if that much if there are two or eight steps
to get a package pushed (as long as it's documented somewhere). You on
the other hand do and you are right with it.
But forcing maintainers to read a high-traffic mailing list just because
they want to maintaining one package is likely something they care
about. So let's please make package maintaining easy for them, too.
More information about the fedora-devel-list