post within a thread when using digest mode? [was: fedora-list Digest, Vol 2, Issue 17]

Joe(theWordy)Philbrook jtwdyp at ttlc.net
Mon Apr 5 02:05:46 UTC 2004


It would appear that on Apr 4, Brian Bober did say:

> Sorry about the subject of this thread btw, I forgot to give it a name.. I'm
> still not sure what I'm posting is appearing in the thread. It might take more
> than giving it the same subject. I'm not sure if its possible to post within a
> thread when using digest mode for a list. Is it?

Well that _MAY_ depend on your mail client. I'm using pine and if I
"view" an "message" attachment and select reply while so viewing, My
reply gets Both the individual subject and the "In-Reply-To:" header
line. I can tell because if I turn on full header mode and look at my
outbox, the "In-Reply-To:" header IS there. But I suppose some brain
dead mail clients don't have the ability to reply to an individual message
attachment and can only reply to the whole list. Which probably breaks
the thread logic (that must frustrate threaded list readers almost as
much as replying to an existing thread with a new topic) or actually, I
wonder if that could cause a threaded reader to sort the new message to
an arbitrarily determined existing thread???? 

Speaking for myself, I think the best way to start a NEW thread would be
to put the lists address in your address book and start a new message
without using "reply"...

BTW: if you can't get your mail client to automatically insert the correct
subject on an reply to a specific message I'd presume the thread will
get messed up on it...

Perhaps one of the threaded list readers would like to help you figure
out how to get YOUR mail client to use the right "In-Reply-To:" header
for replies to existing threads?? 

-- 
|				      ---   ---
|     Joe (theWordy) Philbrook	      <o>   <o>
|	   J(tWdy)P			  ^
|	<<jtwdyp at ttlc.net>>		/---\	"bla bla bla..."
|					\___/	"...and bla..."

   At least I know my mouth is running, I just can't find the off button!





More information about the fedora-list mailing list