A little tip (and maybe a request for quality control?)
Frode Petersen
fropeter at online.no
Sat Sep 8 21:14:04 UTC 2007
Ian Malone wrote:
>> Tim wrote:
>>> How's that different from not playing with gain, and ripping/encoding
>>> them as they are?
>>>
>>
>> Well, albums have different overall levels, making some a lot louder
>> than others (rock albums for instance.) Vorbisgain makes this
>> difference smaller, but retains the dynamic differences between the
>> songs on an album if used in the correct mode.
>>
>
> Perfectly explained. Some albums use full dynamic range of the
> medium, some are heavily dynamically compressed so they sound loud
> all the way through. When you use replaygain you set the player
> volume control to the volume you want to listen to and one album
> doesn't sound louder than another. (Google volume wars)
As an article found googling for volume wars explains, there can be a
problem with clipping of the peaks in the music, creating clicks or
worse artifacts in the sound. That was the reason I started using
vorbisgain. Some music I listen to varies a LOT in volume throughout a
tune and the result was terrible. Vorbisgain analyses both overall level
and peaks, so after using it, the music sounded a lot better.
I guess the kind of music played will determine whether it is
noticeable, and thereby vorbisgain's usefulness. Only YOUR ears can tell.
Here's the article: http://www.geekrants.com/articles/mastering.html
Frode
More information about the fedora-list
mailing list