RFC: Review with Flags (Version 3)

[Warren Togami]

Mamoru Tasaka wrote:
> Warren Togami wrote:
>> Raw notes... your comments would be very much appreciated.
> 
> By the way....
> On current bugzilla system, who can change fedora-review or
> fedora-cvs flags? Especially can new contributor (i.e. who
> want to get sponsored by someone) change the flags?
> A new contributor does not have cvsextras nor fedorabug.

fedora-cvs and fedora-review may be seen by all.
fedora-review? may be set by anyone.
fedora-review- or + may be set only by fedora contributors. (this will 
change in the future to be cvsextras or something)
fedora-cvs? may be set only by fedora contributors.

> 
> If no:
> * submitter (new contributor) cannot revise the flag to
>   fedora-review? from fedora-review- when submitter modified
>   his/her srpm/spec and want to make them checked.
> 
> * And.. who should (and can) change the fedora-cvs flags? A
>   submitter or the reviewer(assignee)? At this time, a new
>   contributor(submitter) should have cvsextras, however,
>   normally he/she does not have fedorabug.
>   Currently, the _submitter_ (new contributor) writes the
>   request on SyncNeeded wiki,
>   however, if submitter _cannot_ change fedora-cvs flags,
>   the _reviewer_(assignee) has to change fedora-cvs flags, as long
>   as only fedorabugs member can change the flag.
> 

Shouldn't the submitter become sponsored before committing?
In any case only fedorabugs group membership is necessary currently in 
order to flip fedora-review and fedora-cvs, although I think we should 
change that to cvsextras later.  (Currently cvsextras does not sync to a 
Bugzilla group.  Several things we have to fix before that is possible.

Warren Togami
wtogami at redhat.com