[Bug 432033] Review Request: crystalspace - Crystal Space a free 3D engine

[bugzilla at redhat.com]

Please do not reply directly to this email. All additional
comments should be made in the comments box of this bug report.

Summary: Review Request: crystalspace - Crystal Space a free 3D engine


https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=432033





------- Additional Comments From mtasaka at ioa.s.u-tokyo.ac.jp  2008-02-16 07:07 EST -------
Created an attachment (id=295066)
 --> (https://bugzilla.redhat.com/attachment.cgi?id=295066&action=view)
License check list for crystalspace

(For non-legal issue, please see my previous comments)
Note:
Unless you specify license tag for subpackages, subpackages
inherits license tag from main package.
For example, currently -doc subpackage has
"License: LGPLv2+ and GPLv2+ and GPLv2".

Legal issue:

GPLv2:
GPLv2/apps/import/maya2spr/binarytree.cpp
  -> maya2spr (in -utils) is GPLv2
GPLv2/scripts/max/exportcsp.mcr
GPLv2/scripts/max/exportlights.mcr
GPLv2/scripts/max/exportsprite.mcr
GPLv2/scripts/max/fixmaterials.mcr
GPLv2/scripts/max/sanitycheck.ms
GPLv2/scripts/max/showMap.mcr
  -> all these files (in -utils) are GPLv2

GPLv2+:
GPLv2+/apps/tests/ceguitest/ceguitest.cpp
GPLv2+/apps/tests/ceguitest/ceguitest.h
  -> ceguitest (in -demos) is GPLv2+
GPLv2+/libs/csplugincommon/sndsys/
  -> libcrystalspace-1.2.so (in main) is GPLv2+ (not LGPLv2+)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
  1810	  echo './out/linuxx86/debug/libs/cstool/memory_pen.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/cstool/csfxscr.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/canvas/scrshot.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/canvas/x11-keys.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/canvas/cursorconvert.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/canvas/softfontcache.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/canvas/fontcache.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/canvas/graph2d.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/imageloader/commonimagefile.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/imageloader/optionsparser.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/particlesys/partgen.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/render3d/txtmgr.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/render3d/normalizationcube.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/renderstep/parserenderstep.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/renderstep/basesteptype.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/renderstep/basesteploader.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/script/scriptcommon.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/shader/shaderprogram.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/sndsys/convert.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/sndsys/cyclicbuf.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/sndsys/sndstream.o@'
'./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/csplugincommon/sndsys/snddata.o@' | sed 's/@ /@/g' |
tr '@' '
  1811	' >> ./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/libcrystalspace-1.2.so.resp
  1812	
  1813	
  1814	  g++ -Wl,--as-needed -shared -o
./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/libcrystalspace-1.2.so
-Wl, at ./out/linuxx86/debug/libs/libcrystalspace-1.2.so.resp  -lm -ldl -lnsl
-Wl,-z,defs -Wl,--warn-unresolved-symbols -Wl,-E -g3 -lpthread -lpthread -lz
-lm -ldl -lnsl -Wl,-z,defs -Wl,--warn-unresolved-symbols -Wl,-E -g3 \
  1815	    -Wl,-soname,libcrystalspace-1.2.so
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
GPLv2+/plugins/sndsys/element/
  -> sndsysXXX.so (in main) is GPLv2+
GPLv2+/plugins/utilities/movierecorder/
  -> movierecorder.so (in main) is GPLv2+ (not GPLv2)
GPLv2+/scripts/jamtemplate/createproject.sh
  -> createproject.sh (in -devel) is GPLv2+

Check for GPLv2+ pollution
root:
GPLv2+/include/csplugincommon/sndsys/snddata.h ->
LGPLv2+/include/csplugincommon.h:#include "csplugincommon/sndsys/snddata.h" ->
LGPLv2+/include/crystalspace.h:#include "csplugincommon.h" ->
File_C_or_C++/plugins/cscript/pycscegui/cs_cegui.cpp:#include "crystalspace.h"
File_C_or_C++/plugins/cscript/csperl5/cswigpl5.cpp:#include "crystalspace.h"
LGPLv2+/apps/tools/genmeshify/converter.cpp:#include "crystalspace.h"
LGPLv2+/apps/tools/genmeshify/genmeshify.cpp:#include "crystalspace.h"
LGPLv2+/apps/tools/genmeshify/processor.cpp:#include "crystalspace.h"
LGPLv2+/apps/tools/genmeshify/stdloadercontext.cpp:#include "crystalspace.h"
LGPLv2+/apps/tools/startme/startme.h:#include <crystalspace.h>
LGPLv2+/apps/tools/lighter2/common.h:#include "crystalspace.h"
LGPLv2+/apps/tools/basemapgen/basemapgen.h:#include "crystalspace.h"
LGPLv2+/apps/tools/heightmapgen/heightmapgen.h:#include "crystalspace.h"
LGPLv2+/apps/tools/partconv/partconv.cpp:#include "crystalspace.h"
( -----------------
LGPLv2+/apps/walktest/walktest.cpp:#include "crystalspace.h"
LGPLv2+/apps/pysimp/pysimp.h:#include <crystalspace.h>
LGPLv2+/apps/tests/imptest/imptest.h:#include <crystalspace.h>
LGPLv2+/apps/tests/eventtest/eventtest.h:#include <crystalspace.h>
LGPLv2+/apps/tests/sndtest/sndtest.h:#include <crystalspace.h>
LGPLv2+/apps/tutorial/pathtut/pathtut.h:#include <crystalspace.h>
LGPLv2+/apps/tutorial/simpcd/simpcd.h:#include <crystalspace.h>
LGPLv2+/apps/tutorial/simple2/simple2.h:#include <crystalspace.h>
LGPLv2+/apps/tutorial/mazing/gamestuff.cpp:#include <crystalspace.h>
LGPLv2+/apps/tutorial/mazing/appmazing.h:#include <crystalspace.h>
LGPLv2+/apps/tutorial/simplept/simplept.h:#include <crystalspace.h>
LGPLv2+/apps/tutorial/phystut/phystut.h:#include <crystalspace.h>
LGPLv2+/apps/tutorial/simpmap/simpmap.h:#include <crystalspace.h>
LGPLv2+/apps/tutorial/simpvs/simpvs.h:#include <crystalspace.h>
LGPLv2+/apps/tutorial/simple1/simple1.h:#include <crystalspace.h>
------------- can be killed )
-> _pycscegui.so (in crystalspace-devel) is polluted
-> Some files in -utils are also polluted

GPLv2+/include/csplugincommon/sndsys/sndstream.h ->
LGPLv2+/include/csplugincommon.h:#include "csplugincommon/sndsys/sndstream.h"
(-> same above)

GPLv2+/include/ivaria/movierecorder.h ->
LGPLv2+/include/ivaria.h:#include "ivaria/movierecorder.h" ->
(-> not pollute any more)

Summary
main  : LGPLv2+ and GPLv2+
-utils: LGPLv2+ and GPLv2+ and GPLv2
-demos: LGPLv2+ and GPLv2+
-devel: LGPLv2+ and GPLv2+
-doc:	????

-- 
Configure bugmail: https://bugzilla.redhat.com/userprefs.cgi?tab=email
------- You are receiving this mail because: -------
You are on the CC list for the bug, or are watching someone who is.