[Fedora-packaging] combining code from GPLv2 and Artistic (Perl)

Chuck Anderson cra at WPI.EDU
Thu Sep 4 21:06:26 UTC 2008


I'm working on packaging perl-RT-Client-REST, a Perl module from CPAN.  
It claims to be under the Perl license (GPL+ or Artistic) except for 
one class, RT::Client::REST, which it claims is under the GPL since 
the author copied those bits from RT, which is in fact under GPLv2 
according to the web site: http://code.bestpractical.com/project/RT (Request Tracker)

Should the License tag be:

License: (GPL+ or Artistic) and GPLv2

or just:

License: GPLv2

or perhaps:

License: GPLv2 or Artistic

?


The README says:

...

Author:
    Dmitri Tikhonov <dtikhonov at yahoo.com>
    RT::Client::REST is based on 'rt' command-line utility distributed
        with RT 3.x written by Abhijit Menon-Sen <ams at wiw.org> and
        donated to RT project.

License:
    Original 'rt' utility is GPL, therefore so is RT::Client::REST.
    The rest of the modules are licensed under the usual artistic
    license.  (I am not sure it makes sense to do this.  Does GPL
    override artistic license?  Someone let me know if you have a
    definite answer.)


The source code mentions that RT::Client::REST is under GPL:

./lib/RT/Client/REST.pm:=head1 LICENSE
./lib/RT/Client/REST.pm:Since original rt is licensed under GPL, so is this module.
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Queue.pm:=head1 LICENSE
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Queue.pm:Perl license with the exception of L<RT::Client::REST>, which is GPLed.
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Attachment.pm:=head1 LICENSE
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Attachment.pm:Perl license with the exception of L<RT::Client::REST>, which is GPLed.
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Transaction.pm:=head1 LICENSE
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Transaction.pm:Perl license with the exception of L<RT::Client::REST>, which is GPLed.
./lib/RT/Client/REST/User.pm:=head1 LICENSE
./lib/RT/Client/REST/User.pm:Perl license with the exception of L<RT::Client::REST>, which is GPLed.
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Ticket.pm:=head1 LICENSE
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Ticket.pm:Perl license with the exception of L<RT::Client::REST>, which is GPLed.

AFAICT these are where the RT::Client::REST class and derived classes 
are defined:

./lib/RT/Client/REST.pm:package RT::Client::REST;
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Queue.pm:package RT::Client::REST::Queue;
./lib/RT/Client/REST/HTTPClient.pm:package RT::Client::REST::HTTPClient;
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Forms.pm:package RT::Client::REST::Forms;
./lib/RT/Client/REST/SearchResult.pm:package RT::Client::REST::SearchResult;
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Object.pm:package RT::Client::REST::Object;
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Object.pm:  package RT::Client::REST::MyType;
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Attachment.pm:package RT::Client::REST::Attachment;
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Transaction.pm:package RT::Client::REST::Transaction;
./lib/RT/Client/REST/User.pm:package RT::Client::REST::User;
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Ticket.pm:package RT::Client::REST::Ticket;
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Exception.pm:package RT::Client::REST::Exception;
./lib/RT/Client/REST/Object/Exception.pm:package RT::Client::REST::Object::Exception;


Thanks.




More information about the Fedora-packaging mailing list