What is the mkisofs license?

Jonathan Corbet lwn-fedora-test at lwn.net
Sat Aug 12 18:33:22 UTC 2006


Sigh.  I love writing "license mess" articles.

After reading a bunch of classic Shilling mail on another mailing list,
I did an "rpm -qi mkisofs" on my rawhide^WFedora development system.
Here's a few lines of what I got...

  Name        : mkisofs                      Relocations: (not relocatable)
  Version     : 2.01.01.0.a10                     Vendor: Red Hat, Inc.
  [...]
  Size        : 1651183                          License: CDDL

The interesting thing is that mkisofs is *not* licensed under the CDDL.
The code has copyrights going back to 1993 (Yggdrasil!), and it is
clearly a GPL-licensed program.

According to the source, mkisofs uses libscg, which, in the 2.01.01
release, *is* licensed under the CDDL.  Which says to me (and a bunch of
people on the Debian lists) that the resulting combination is not
distributable. 

Is this issue on Fedora's radar?  There may be trouble brewing here...

jon




More information about the fedora-test-list mailing list