davej at redhat.com
Tue Mar 7 21:38:47 UTC 2006
On Tue, Mar 07, 2006 at 01:31:09PM -0800, Josh wrote:
> Hello testers,
> After a fresh FC5T3 install, i was configuring my USB wireless network
> dongle and couldn't find ndiswrapper on the FC5T3 CD.
it's deliberatly not shipped.
> I may have overlooked. Is there a reason not to bundle ndiswrapper with FC5T3?
- it creates a situation where if you get a kernel bug, I'm not even going
to look at it, because *anything* could have happened, and as the driver
is effectively binary only, there's nothing I can do about it.
- it reinforces the message to hardware vendors that it's ok to not
release documentation or native Linux drivers, because 'they can just use
the windows driver'. This is not a 'might happen' btw, there are already
companies saying this when you call them to ask for documentation.
The fact that other distros are shipping this is really sad.
Given a lot of ex-Windows users fled that platform because they were tired
of crashes, I'm amazed that people now want to run the drivers from it, when
a lot of the time, they were the cause of the problems.
I know it sucks to have hardware that you can't use. I've got a similar
device myself that doesn't work right now. But there's hope that at
some point the bcm43xx driver will work with it. Testing, and providing
feedback to developers of *native* drivers is the direction we want
to be headed toward.
More information about the fedora-test-list