[Freeipa-devel] [PATCH] 938 consolidate external member code

[Rob Crittenden]

Martin Kosek wrote:
> On Wed, 2012-02-01 at 16:45 -0500, Rob Crittenden wrote:
>> We had code all over the place to handle adding and removing external
>> members from a variety of attributes. I consolidated these all into two
>> functions in baseldap.py.
>>
>> This obsoletes my patch 920 but this patch includes the improved error
>> reporting that was present.
>>
>> rob
>
> Hm, good patch! 89 insertions and 283 deletions, I like that.
>
> Still, I saw some minor issues that this patch introduced:
>
> 1) Extraneous line in failed list:
>
> # ipa hbacrule-show foo
>    Rule name: foo
>    Enabled: TRUE
>    External host: foo.example.com
> # ipa hbacrule-add-sourcehost foo --hosts=foo.example.com
>    Rule name: foo
>    Enabled: TRUE
>    External host: foo.example.com
>    Failed source hosts/hostgroups:
>      member host: foo.example.com: This entry is already a member
>      member host group:<<<<<<<<
> -------------------------
> Number of members added 0
> -------------------------
>
> 2) Empty external host list when all of its values was removed:
>
> # ipa hbacrule-remove-sourcehost foo --hosts=foo.example.com
>    Rule name: foo
>    Enabled: TRUE
>    External host:<<<<<<<<  Empty list
> ---------------------------
> Number of members removed 1
> ---------------------------
>
> 3) sudorule-{add|remove}-runasuser does not show failed additions:
>
> # ipa sudorule-add-runasuser foo --users=admin,foo --groups=admins
>    Rule name: foo
>    Enabled: TRUE
>    RunAs Users: admin
>    Groups of RunAs Users: admins
>    RunAs External User: foo
> -------------------------
> Number of members added 3
> -------------------------
>
> # ipa sudorule-add-runasuser foo --users=admin,foo --groups=admins,foo
>    Rule name: foo
>    Enabled: TRUE
>    RunAs Users: admin
>    Groups of RunAs Users: admins
> -------------------------
> Number of members added 0<<<<  Error messages missing
> -------------------------
>
> 4) The same issue is with sudorule-{add|remove}-runasgroup:
> # ipa sudorule-remove-runasgroup foo --groups=admins,foo
>    Rule name: foo
>    Enabled: TRUE
> ---------------------------
> Number of members removed 0
> ---------------------------
>
> Although this problem was there before your patch, we may create a
> separate ticket if you want.
>
> Martin
>

I don't think that #1 and #2 are problems. It is extraneous perhaps.

I don't see any failures in #3, what errors would you expect?

In any case I don't think any of of these are caused by my changes, I'd 
prefer to open new tickets on them (and we'll have only one place to fix 
some of them).

rob