jim.kinney at gmail.com
Sun Mar 18 16:46:03 UTC 2012
On Sat, Mar 17, 2012 at 5:10 PM, Bill Fitzgerald <bill at funnymonkey.com>wrote:
> Some thoughts inline, below -
>> When one finds a cutesy novelty 'teaching
>> tool' they seen in a magazine ,it is shortly monkey see, monkey do.
> These are teachable moments; by far the greatest challenge I have
> seen/experienced is getting people to set aside preconceived notions and
> actually listen/converse. Many issues masquerade as "technical problems"
> when the real issues/barriers are carbon-based.
I concur. Many teachers are trying too hard to show improvement and they
will lock onto to ANYTHING that shows promise. Sadly, the school process
that teachers go through to qualify them for the job makes them totally
unsuitable to do the type of evaluation required to determine if a
particular tool, technology, or process has the effect they think it does.
In other words, they are trying to do psychology experiments but have no
scientific background or training in how to set upo and devise controls,
etc. for any type of experiment.
So the challenge for us tech geeks is we have to get them to explain what
they are trying to do from a teaching standpoint, and we have to understand
it. Then we have to go searching for tools that
1. run on our platforms
2. do what they think they need
After nearly 10 years teaching college level physics and astronomy, the
best technology is that which is invisible. Much of what I see being pushed
at schools and teachers by vendors is the robotic teacher replacement drone
garbage - practice drills with little to no knowledge enhancement.
Invisible technology is like when looking for a specific TV program, they
change the channel. The technology behind the process is "magic" yet
accepted. Sadly, a teacher sees some web-based multimedia <insert other
buzz words here> and because it "works" like changing the channel, the
common assumption is the education process will also work the same. So by
getting the teacher to do the evaluation of what that "tool the must have"
really does, often they will find that a pencil and paper is more effective.
I cringe daily looking at the text books my kids use in K12. Color and
pictures take up money and space (which is money in publishing). Designing
a book to have a full color picture on EVERY page doesn't encourage
learning if the picture is not relevant to the text on the page. So the
books got huge and very expensive and now they are causing back pain in
kids who have text book based homework every night in every subject. A 65
pound kids can't carry a 30 pound book-bag.
A web video can be informative but must be used in the context of other
solid instructional methods. Migrating from paper to e-book will certainly
make carrying the contents easier but the educational content is being
diluted by the publishers. It makes the school district book review
committee happy to see books, electronic or dead tree, with the important
word highlighted and a per chapter glossary and a short chapter summary.
Too bad that crap eliminates ALL of the student's learning process as they
no longer have to figure this out on their own.
The open text books group is doing it (mostly) right. The tech part still
missing is an easy to use tool for student annotation of the PDF files that
is transportable (i.e. their notes can "stick" with the PDF version and can
be easily transferred to someone else). Tablets are nice but a tablet with
a pen is even better. The ability to highlight a word or sentence or add a
personal definition or reference in the margin will make the open text
books better than the dead tree texts. The will make them belong to each
If there is a way for the teachers to review the student's notes in their
books and add extra comments, etc, wow! personalized teaching at the K12
James P. Kinney III
As long as the general population is passive, apathetic, diverted to
consumerism or hatred of the vulnerable, then the powerful can do as they
please, and those who survive will be left to contemplate the outcome.
- *2011 Noam Chomsky
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the K12OSN