[libvirt-users] Hook problem

[David Gilmour]

I am trying to use /etc/libvirt/hooks/qemu to control the startup of several guests with interdependencies.  The goal is to delay the start of guest B until the DNS server on guest A is running.  To accomplish this, I wrote a qemu hook script that detects the normal startup of guest B and start a second script in the background to wait until the preconditions to start B are fulfilled, then start B using a call to the virsh command.

For this strategy to work, it must handle the case where libvirt has chosen guest B as the first guest to attempt to start.  (Although renaming the symlinks in /etc/libvirt/qemu/autostart to force starting the guests in a particular order might work, I do not want to rely on this undocumented behavior).  In the case where libvirt happens to attempt to start guest B before it starts guest A, the hook script needs to somehow tell libvirt to skip guest B and go on to starting the next guest.  Otherwise a deadlock would result as libvirt waited for B to start, but B was waiting for A to start.   I have tried to handle this by returning failure from the hook script for the initial attempt to start B once the background script has been started to implement the DNS check and eventually the delayed start of B.

Unfortunately, I cannot find a way to force libvirt to continue until the background script exits.  No combination of background execution, nohup, disown, setsid -f, or at seems to detach the process sufficiently to "fool" libvirt into acting on the "exit 1" line in the qemu script and proceed on to start other guests.  As a result, the dependency of B on A deadlocks, and neither guest ever starts.

Can someone please either find an error in my approach or propose a different strategy to implement this customized dependency of the startup of one guest on another?

Thanks -

======

Here is my qemu script:

#!/bin/bash
if [[ "$2" == 'start' ]]; then
        echo "$0: Starting $1..." |& logger
        if [[ "$1" == 'B' ]]; then
            # The next line is where the background script is invoked
                /bin/bash /usr/local/bin/startB &
            # These also don't work:
            # (/bin/bash /usr/local/bin/startB) & ; disown
# setsid -f (/bin/bash /usr/local/bin/startB) & ; disown
            # Unfortunately, the exit in the following line doesn't force libvirt to move on to the next guest to start until the background command has itself exited
                exit 1;
        fi
fi

Here is the startB script, including a call to a program named in the $dnssuccess variable that does the testing of DNS availability on guest A:

#!/bin/bash
until $dnssuccess
do
    echo "$0: Delaying start of guest B 10 seconds" |& logger
    sleep 10;
done
# It's now OK to start guest
echo "$0: Now starting guest B" |& logger
virsh start B;

=====
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://listman.redhat.com/archives/libvirt-users/attachments/20190130/8ca4666a/attachment.htm>