OOM killer "Out of Memory: Killed process" SOLUTIONS / SUMMARY

[Eric Sisler]

Since this problem seems to popup on different lists, this message has
been cross-posted to the general Red Hat discussion list, the RHEL3
(Taroon) list and the RHEL4 (Nahant) list.  My apologies for not having
the time to post this summary sooner.

I would still be banging my head against this problem were it not for
the generous assistance of Tom Sightler <ttsig at tuxyturvy.com> and Brian
Long <brilong at cisco.com>.

In general, the out of memory killer (oom-killer) begins killing
processes, even on servers with large amounts (6Gb+) of RAM.  In many
cases people report plenty of "free" RAM and are perplexed as to why the
oom-killer is whacking processes.  Indications that this has happened
appear in /var/log/messages:
  Out of Memory: Killed process [PID] [process name].

In my case I was upgrading various VMware servers from RHEL3 / VMware
GSX to RHEL4 / VMware Server.  One of the virtual machines on a server
with 16Gb of RAM kept getting whacked by the oom-killer.  Needless to
say, this was quite frustrating.

As it turns out, the problem was low memory exhaustion.  Quoting Tom:
"The kernel uses low memory to track allocations of all memory thus a
system with 16GB of memory will use significantly more low memory than a
system with 4GB, perhaps as much as 4 times.  This extra pressure
happens from the moment you turn the system on before you do anything at
all because the kernel structures have to be sized for the potential of
tracking allocations in four times as much memory."

You can check the status of low & high memory a couple of ways:

# egrep 'High|Low' /proc/meminfo
HighTotal:     5111780 kB
HighFree:         1172 kB
LowTotal:       795688 kB
LowFree:         16788 kB

# free -lm
             total       used       free     shared    buffers     cached
Mem:          5769       5751         17          0          8       5267
Low:           777        760         16          0          0          0
High:         4991       4990          1          0          0          0
-/+ buffers/cache:        475       5293
Swap:         4773          0       4773

When low memory is exhausted, it doesn't matter how much high memory is
available, the oom-killer will begin whacking processes to keep the
server alive.

There are a couple of solutions to this problem:

If possible, upgrade to 64-bit Linux.  This is the best solution because
*all* memory becomes low memory.  If you run out of low memory in this
case, then you're *really* out of memory. ;-)

If limited to 32-bit Linux, the best solution is to run the hugemem
kernel.  This kernel splits low/high memory differently, and in most
cases should provide enough low memory to map high memory.  In most
cases this is an easy fix - simply install the hugemem kernel RPM &
reboot.

If running the 32-bit hugemem kernel isn't an option either, you can try
setting /proc/sys/vm/lower_zone_protection to a value of 250 or more.
This will cause the kernel to try to be more aggressive in defending the
low zone from allocating memory that could potentially be allocated in
the high memory zone.  As far as I know, this option isn't available
until the 2.6.x kernel. Some experimentation to find the best setting
for your environment will probably be necessary.  You can check & set
this value on the fly via:
  # cat /proc/sys/vm/lower_zone_protection
  # echo "250" > /proc/sys/vm/lower_zone_protection

To set this option on boot, add the following to /etc/sysctl.conf:
  vm.lower_zone_protection = 250

As a last-ditch effort, you can disable the oom-killer.  This option can
cause the server to hang, so use it with extreme caution (and at your
own risk)!
Check status of oom-killer:
  # cat /proc/sys/vm/oom-kill

Turn oom-killer off/on:
  # echo "0" > /proc/sys/vm/oom-kill
  # echo "1" > /proc/sys/vm/oom-kill

To make this change take effect at boot time, add the following
to /etc/sysctl.conf:
  vm.oom-kill = 0

For processes that would have been killed, but weren't because the oom-
killer is disabled, you'll see the following message
in /var/log/messages:
  "Would have oom-killed but /proc/sys/vm/oom-kill is disabled"

Sorry for being so long-winded.  I hope this helps others who have
struggled with this problem.

-Eric

-- 
Eric Sisler <esisler at westminster.lib.co.us>
Library Network Specialist
Westminster Public Library
Westminster, CO USA

Linux - Don't fear the Penguin.
Want to know what we use Linux for?
Visit http://wallace.westminster.lib.co.us/linux