[vfio-users] How to choose a compatible motherboard?

[Nick Sukharev]

I certainly don't get the login prompt but it displays the GRUB there and
some text before it switches to my USB video. As long as it doesn't change
the text mode resolution or do anything with the card other than just text
output, it seems to work OK with W7 OVFM guest. Somehow it also works
without the ROM file while printing those messages. In any case, going
headless only makes sense if you really need it as in my case where I want
to use all 4 PCIE slots.  I wonder what would ACS give me considering that
I am already getting separate groups for each of my GPUs + their audio
component? I considered a Xeon for my setup but the cost was much higher.

On Thu, Oct 22, 2015 at 1:33 PM, Alex Williamson <
alex.l.williamson at gmail.com> wrote:

> On Thu, Oct 22, 2015 at 2:14 PM, Nick Sukharev <nicksukharev at gmail.com>
> wrote:
>
>> I had this issue with my 1st PCIE slot. Three steps helped:
>> 1) disabling radeon driver by
>> creating /etc/modprobe.d/blacklistradeon.conf with a single line
>> blacklist radeon
>> 2) specifying GRUB_CMDLINE_LINUX="nomodeset vga=normal video=vesafb:off"
>> in /etc/default/grub
>> 3) Using "pure" OVMF.
>>
>
> Don't you still get a VGA mode login prompt on the primary graphics on the
> host?  That means the host is writing into the VGA space of the device,
> even while the device is in use by the guest.  Maybe it doesn't cause any
> noticeable problem since you're using OVMF, but it's still concerning.
> I've tried this in the past and bumped a keyboard connected to the host
> while the guest (Linux) was in text mode and got a host login prompt on the
> guest-owned graphics... very confusing.  I think there's a step missing
> here about detaching the VGA device from vgacon.
>
>
>> I am pretty sure steps 1 and 3 are also required for secondary slots on
>> my MB unless I want to use just one non-gpu slot for gpu, then it works
>> with seabios.
>> I still get this in dmesg:
>> vfio-pci 0000:03:00.0: Invalid ROM contents
>> but no issues because of that.
>>
>
> Linux has special handling for the boot VGA ROM, it's read from the shadow
> ROM at 0xc0000, which isn't ROM at all and often gets modified by the ROM
> execution at boot time.  Primary graphics, even if not used for a console,
> is therefore always more likely to need the ROM passed as a file.
>
>
>> I was trying to make all PCIE slots available for passthrough, if that is
>> not required some old NVidia in the 1st slot and a radeon in the 2nd (or
>> vice versa) should be easier. With 1,2,3 I can go completely "headless" in
>> the sense that I am using USB graphhics on that machine for host.
>> Also, Haswell i7-5820K works perfectly for x99 socket 2011-3, no need to
>> go for a Xenon. I doubt you can get 6 core Xenon for a comparable price.
>>
>
> "perfectly" minus not supporting ACS on the processor root ports.  There
> is still a reason to go for a Xeon.
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://listman.redhat.com/archives/vfio-users/attachments/20151022/d9cb984e/attachment.htm>